The news of Hu Yaobang's death was slowly sinking in on April 16, 1989. Spontaneous memorial banners, flowers, and Big Posters were appearing in college campuses all over the country. Dozens of small flowers and wreaths also showed up at the Monument to People's Heroes at Tiananmen Square. There were not yet organized activities.
There were many rumors. Most centered on the theme that Hu Yaobang suffered a heart attack because the continued criticisms he was receiving during recent politburo meetings. Although baseless and most likely to be false, the rumors were wide spread and casting Hu Yaobang as the victim of other leaders such as Li Peng and Deng Xiaoping.
Among the banners, the most eye-catching was one that proclaimed, "The one who should have died did not; the one who should not have died did!" The quotation was attributed to Bing Xin, a famous author who was almost ninety years old. She was referring to her own advanced age while mourning for the death of the younger Hu Yaobang.
Yet the message immediately took on a new meaning in the public. "The one who should have died" was taken to refer to Deng Xiaoping, the old man who had wronged Hu Yaobang more than two years ago.
Meanwhile, a group of young teachers at the University of Political Science and Law were spending the day preparing for a giant wreath. This was the idea of Wu Renhua, who had graduated from Peking University. After almost an entire day of work, the wreath came to be almost seven feet in diameter and covered with paper flowers and banners. They placed the wreath at the center of the campus with an unsigned note announcing that the wreath would be delivered to Tiananmen Square at one o'clock next afternoon.
Wu Renhua did not know how many, if any, students from that conservative campus would join him.
Days of 1989
How Chinese Students Shocked the World with a Magnificent Movement for Democracy and Liberty that Ended in the Tragic Tiananmen Massacre in 1989.
Relive the history with this blog and my book, "Standoff at Tiananmen", a narrative history of the movement.
Thursday, April 16, 2009
Wednesday, April 15, 2009
Days of 1989: A Chronology
Recounting the days of 1989, one day at a time
July
June
May
April
May
- May 31, 1989
- May 30, 1989
- May 29, 1989
- May 28, 1989
- May 27, 1989
- May 26, 1989
- May 25, 1989
- May 24, 1989
- May 23, 1989
- May 22, 1989
- May 21, 1989
- May 20, 1989
- May 19, 1989
- May 18, 1989
- May 17, 1989
- May 16, 1989
- May 15, 1989
- May 14, 1989
- May 13, 1989
- May 12, 1989
- May 11, 1989
- May 10, 1989
- May 9, 1989
- May 8, 1989
- May 7, 1989
- May 6, 1989
- May 5, 1989
- May 4, 1989
- May 3, 1989
- May 2, 1989
- May 1, 1989
April
- April 30, 1989
- April 29, 1989
- April 28, 1989
- April 27, 1989
- April 26, 1989
- April 25, 1989
- April 24, 1989
- April 23, 1989
- April 22, 1989
- April 21, 1989
- April 20, 1989
- April 19, 1989
- April 18, 1989
- April 17, 1989
- April 16, 1989
- April 15, 1989
February
January
- February 26, 1989: Fang Lizhi was prevented from attending Bush's banquet
- February 13, 1989: 33 Writers cosigned an open letter supporting Fang Lizhi
January
This Day in 1989: April 15, Hu Yaobang is Dead
Former General Secretary Hu Yaobang passed away at 7:53 in the morning of April 15, 1989. The news was officially broadcast to the nation in the evening news hour, accompanied by the usual funeral music and superlative praises for his life's work. Although he had been disposed a couple of years earlier, the official obituary still referred to him as "a loyal Communist soldier who had withstood many tests, a great proletarian revolutionary and politician, an outstanding political worker in the Chinese army, a marvelous leader who had held important Party leadership positions for many years." -- although it did omit the highest praise of "a great Marxist."
The news had already been leaked out throughout the day. There were immediate, but tentative, reactions in some of the college campuses. In the afternoon, Big Posters and banners started to show up in public places in, at least, Peking University, People's University, and Tsinghua University. Some people were observed as delivering wreaths to the residence of Hu Yaobang.
In that evening, as the news was officially confirmed, the first sign of memorial at Tiananmen Square appeared. It was a small white flower at the base of the Monument to People's Heroes, reportedly placed by a soldier. The number of Big Posters at the Triangle of Peking University ballooned to close to 100. Hundreds of students started to gather there in their usual mode of discussion when there was a significant news.
April 15 was also the birthday of Chai Ling. Her husband Feng Congde bought a cake for the occasion. They watched the news but did not think too much of it other than, like most students, feeling sorry for Hu Yaobang who was known for losing his job trying to protect students involved in previous student movements.
Wang Dan was at home when he got the news around noon. Anticipating something was going to happen, he rode his bike to Peking University in the afternoon. That evening, he was interviewed by the New York Times at the Triangle in the school.
The U. S. Ambassador Winston Lord was scheduled to finish his tour in China. His wife Bettie Bao Lord invited many prominent intellectuals for a farewell party in their residence that night. News of Hu Yaobang's death was whispered from person to person. The author Lao Gui and Dai Qing briefly exchanged views. Both of them were thinking of the possibility of a repeat of April 5, 1976.
Days of 1989
The news had already been leaked out throughout the day. There were immediate, but tentative, reactions in some of the college campuses. In the afternoon, Big Posters and banners started to show up in public places in, at least, Peking University, People's University, and Tsinghua University. Some people were observed as delivering wreaths to the residence of Hu Yaobang.
In that evening, as the news was officially confirmed, the first sign of memorial at Tiananmen Square appeared. It was a small white flower at the base of the Monument to People's Heroes, reportedly placed by a soldier. The number of Big Posters at the Triangle of Peking University ballooned to close to 100. Hundreds of students started to gather there in their usual mode of discussion when there was a significant news.
April 15 was also the birthday of Chai Ling. Her husband Feng Congde bought a cake for the occasion. They watched the news but did not think too much of it other than, like most students, feeling sorry for Hu Yaobang who was known for losing his job trying to protect students involved in previous student movements.
Wang Dan was at home when he got the news around noon. Anticipating something was going to happen, he rode his bike to Peking University in the afternoon. That evening, he was interviewed by the New York Times at the Triangle in the school.
The U. S. Ambassador Winston Lord was scheduled to finish his tour in China. His wife Bettie Bao Lord invited many prominent intellectuals for a farewell party in their residence that night. News of Hu Yaobang's death was whispered from person to person. The author Lao Gui and Dai Qing briefly exchanged views. Both of them were thinking of the possibility of a repeat of April 5, 1976.
Days of 1989
Tuesday, April 14, 2009
People of 1989: Hu Yaobang (胡耀邦)
Not many people knew his name when he first emerged in the national scene in 1981, being appointed as the Chairman of the Chinese Communist Party after Deng Xiaoping successfully purged the last remaining Maoist factions. Hu Yaobang's most remarkable feature was his height. He was even shorter than the diminutive Deng Xiaoping himself, leading to murmured jokes about Deng Xiaoping's selection process.
Hu Yaobang quickly showed that he was quite a character of his own. Before ascending to the top of the national power, in paper anyway, he had worked diligently on behalf of Deng Xiaoping's efforts. In charge of the Party's personnel matters, he had spearheaded the campaign to rectify the millions of cases in which people were wronged during the Cultural Revolution, collecting valuable political capital along the way. There were many anectodal evidence that he had some personal involvement in the grass-root Democracy Wall Movement.
Yet he was still best known for his work on the youth front. Having joined the Communist Party as a teenager, Hu Yaobang had always been in charge of the younger generation during the revolutionary years. It was during the years when he served as the head of the Communist Youth League that he built up a solid power base.
After the post of the Party Chairman was abolished in 1982, Hu Yaobang continued to serve as the nominal head of the Party as its General Secretary. He was responsible in dealing with the many ideological ambiguities that were arising from the great reform and generally kept an open mind. Indeed, his willingness to challenge both the authordox and the tradition often surprised most people. He advocated the abolishment of the "Mao Suit" and replaced it with western jacket and necktie as the official attire. He encouraged the youth to enjoy social dancing, albeit within the confine of officially approved dancing forms. He suggested the nation to give up eating with chopsticks. But above all, he publicly stated that Marxism did not have all the answers.
Hu Yaobang's open-mindedness was seriously challenged during the 1980s as student movements started to emerge as a potent force for social change. He consistently maintained a policy of leniency toward the student trouble-makers, even though a movement during the fall of 1985 was perceived to be against him personally. It was the wide-spread student protests near the end of 1986 that finally did him in. He was forced to resign in January, 1987, for having failed to uphold Deng Xiaoping's famous Four Cardinal Principles.
Hu Yaobang lingered on in the Politiburo for a couple of more years although his portfolio was diminished. By the spring of 1989, he was already a forgotten man. His death on April 15, 1989, however, awakened tremendous emotions within college students, who felt guilty for his fate. Within days, spontaneous marches in his honor appeared in the streets of Beijing and the magnificent movement of 1989 was underway.
Because of his short statue, Hu Yaobang's feet could not touch ground when he sat in the chairs to deliver his enthusiastic speeches. He would always punches the air with his fist while his feet dangled. This cartoonish figure was often ridiculed as unfitting for an elder statesman. But Hu Yaobang would always remembered as a "young leader", despite the fact that he was already seventy-three years old when he died. His energy, kindness, and high-spirit masked his true age and, in the end, made him the rare annoying but endearing personality to college students and the populace at large.
People of 1989
Saturday, April 11, 2009
Associated Press Reports on Tiananmen Survivor
The media countdown to the twentieth anniversary of Tiananmen Massacre has unofficially started as the Associated Press features a survivor telling his story. Qi Zhiyong (齐志勇), who lost a leg near Chang'an Avenue during the night of the massacre has been telling his story for all these years. In fact, he once turned down a sizable amount of money from the government when he learned that the money came with the condition for his silence.
Five years ago, at the fifteenth anniversary, Qi Zhiyong was also profiled by BBC News.
Five years ago, at the fifteenth anniversary, Qi Zhiyong was also profiled by BBC News.
Monday, April 6, 2009
People of 1989: Fang Zheng (方政)
Fang Zheng was one of the hundreds of thousands students who had participated the 1989 student movement pretty much anonymously. Nobody probably would have noticed him if not for the few terrible seconds in the early morning of June 4, 1989.
In that fateful morning, Fang Zheng was walking near the tail end of student formation as they withdrew from Tiananmen Square and on their way back to campuses. At Liubukou, they crossed Chang'an Avenue and slowly walked along its wide bicycle path toward west. He met up with a female student from his school, Beijing Sports College, and they walked together as he comforted the frightened female. It was then they heard the rumble of approaching tanks. Looking back, he got a brief glimpse of several tanks charging in from behind while shooting teargas canisters. Terrified chaos erupted all around them. In the heavy smoke, the female student fainted. Fang Zheng struggled to push her onto the sidewalk, which was blocked by an iron fence. After a final desperate shove, he managed to get his companion onto the fence but that left himself no time to escape. The last thing he remembered was that both of his legs were caught under the tracks of a tank and separated from his own body.
Fang Zheng survived. The female student he had saved was under tremendous pressure from authorities and refused to validate the circumstances of his injury. He was expelled from school and left to survive on his own.
In 1992, he won gold medals in discus and javelin throwing in the All-China Paralympics Games. But his dream of playing in Special Olympics was crushed for political reasons. His story was recently profiled in The Independent.
Fang Zheng and his family finally arrived in America recently where they plan to start a new chapter in life. They are sponsored by Humanitarian China, a fund established by former student leaders including Zhou Fengsuo and Feng Congde. During a brief trip to San Francisco this weekend I had the pleasure to meet Fang Zheng and his wife, who had come to his side during his darkest years. Despite the hardship and an uncertain future, they displayed amazingly great spirits and optimism.
Updated on 9/3/2009: Fang Zheng is standing up again.
Updated on 10/8/2009: Fang Zheng is dancing with his wife.
Saturday, April 4, 2009
Historical Events: April Fifth Movement
The year 1976 was a pivotal year in the history of modern China. The decade-old Cultural Revolution had not yet officially ended but largely faded away. Within that year, top leaders of the first-generation communist revolutionaries, including Mao Zedong and Zhou Enlai, would pass away. A devastating earthquake would shake a large city and cause hundreds of thousands deaths. Mao Zedong's own death in the fall was followed by the ouster of his closest allies in a palace coup that would eventually pave the way for the resurrection of Deng Xiaoping.
The harbinger of things to come for that year occurred days after the new year's day. On January 8, the beloved premier Zhou Enlai succumbed to cancer. Fearing for growing dissent, the government downplayed the memorial activities that winter. People, who had come to see Zhou Enlai as a kinder and gentler alternative to Chairman Mao Zedong himself, were left unsatisfied.
April 4, 1976 was the Qingming festival, the Chinese equivalent of memorial day. Spontaneously, Beijing residents came to Tiananmen Square in thousands to lay wreathes and flowers at the base of the Monument to People's Heroes. Banners, posters, and poems were dedicated to the late premier who had died three months ago. Many of them expressed anger and dissatisfaction to the governing regime.
The next day, April 5, people returned to the Square and found all their dedications cleaned away. Angry crowd grew into a massive protest. Tens of thousands of them milled around the Square in bursts of demonstrations. In a couple of occasions, they threatened to storm the Great Hall of People but did not actually carry it out. While a few of their representatives were engaged in a fruitless negotiation with the authorities, mobs overturned a few government vehicles in the Square and set a small building on fire.
That night, tens of thousands police and workers militia armed with clubs and belts rushed into the Square and forcefully cleared the scene. Numerous injuries, but no deaths, were reported. In the ensuring aftermath, the authorities stripped Deng Xiaoping, who had briefly returned to power under Zhou Enlai's protection, all his titles and blamed him as the conspirator behind the movement. Activists identified from the crowd were jailed for "counter-revolutionary" crimes. It was not until more than two years later, after Deng Xiaoping regained power again, that the verdict of the event was overturned. The jailed activists were then hailed as heroes.
Chen Ziming was one of those young activists on the scene but he escaped capture by chance. He was in Beijing at the time during a furlough from his forced stay in a labor camp, where he was sent after expressing dissenting opinions in personal correspondences. He returned to the labor camp after the movement was suppressed. Even though his pictures were showcased in newspapers in the ensuring manhunt, nobody bothered to check those who had already been detained.
Wang Juntao was not as lucky. He was only seventeen years old and in high school at the time. But he led his class into the Square to join the movement and posted two of his own poems. He was put in jail for more than a year. Later, as a national hero, Wang Juntao was anointed as a potential future leader and received much of public fame. But he quickly abandoned them by plunging into even more dissident activities.
The still younger Shen Tong also experienced this movement first hand when his father took him to the Square to read the poems. He was too young, however, to actually comprehend what was going on.
The April Fifth Movement, although brief, laid a solid ground for the expression the public sentiment supporting the reform ideas of Deng Xiaoping. It would only take the death of Mao Zedong half a year later to open the door.
The harbinger of things to come for that year occurred days after the new year's day. On January 8, the beloved premier Zhou Enlai succumbed to cancer. Fearing for growing dissent, the government downplayed the memorial activities that winter. People, who had come to see Zhou Enlai as a kinder and gentler alternative to Chairman Mao Zedong himself, were left unsatisfied.
April 4, 1976 was the Qingming festival, the Chinese equivalent of memorial day. Spontaneously, Beijing residents came to Tiananmen Square in thousands to lay wreathes and flowers at the base of the Monument to People's Heroes. Banners, posters, and poems were dedicated to the late premier who had died three months ago. Many of them expressed anger and dissatisfaction to the governing regime.
The next day, April 5, people returned to the Square and found all their dedications cleaned away. Angry crowd grew into a massive protest. Tens of thousands of them milled around the Square in bursts of demonstrations. In a couple of occasions, they threatened to storm the Great Hall of People but did not actually carry it out. While a few of their representatives were engaged in a fruitless negotiation with the authorities, mobs overturned a few government vehicles in the Square and set a small building on fire.
That night, tens of thousands police and workers militia armed with clubs and belts rushed into the Square and forcefully cleared the scene. Numerous injuries, but no deaths, were reported. In the ensuring aftermath, the authorities stripped Deng Xiaoping, who had briefly returned to power under Zhou Enlai's protection, all his titles and blamed him as the conspirator behind the movement. Activists identified from the crowd were jailed for "counter-revolutionary" crimes. It was not until more than two years later, after Deng Xiaoping regained power again, that the verdict of the event was overturned. The jailed activists were then hailed as heroes.
Chen Ziming was one of those young activists on the scene but he escaped capture by chance. He was in Beijing at the time during a furlough from his forced stay in a labor camp, where he was sent after expressing dissenting opinions in personal correspondences. He returned to the labor camp after the movement was suppressed. Even though his pictures were showcased in newspapers in the ensuring manhunt, nobody bothered to check those who had already been detained.
Wang Juntao was not as lucky. He was only seventeen years old and in high school at the time. But he led his class into the Square to join the movement and posted two of his own poems. He was put in jail for more than a year. Later, as a national hero, Wang Juntao was anointed as a potential future leader and received much of public fame. But he quickly abandoned them by plunging into even more dissident activities.
The still younger Shen Tong also experienced this movement first hand when his father took him to the Square to read the poems. He was too young, however, to actually comprehend what was going on.
The April Fifth Movement, although brief, laid a solid ground for the expression the public sentiment supporting the reform ideas of Deng Xiaoping. It would only take the death of Mao Zedong half a year later to open the door.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

