Thursday, May 8, 2008

In 1984, How Hu Yaobang Had Invited 3,000 Japanese Youth To China

It was one of the out-of-nowhere things Hu Yaobang did when he was the Party General Secretary. During a state visit to Japan in the November of 1983, he shocked everybody, including his host, by announcing the invitation for 3,000 Japanese youth on a good-will visit to China.

As President Hu Jintao is having his own state visit to Japan, Beijing News carried a recollection of that event a quarter of century ago. Hu Jintao happened to be the General Secretary of the Chiense Communist Youth League at the time and spearheaded the hosting duty.

Danwei provides a summary translation of the recollection.

Hu Yaobang's grandiose gesture was not well received domestically. Most people thought it was a big waste of nation's resources. Many resented the decision after the Japanese government failed to give a reciprocal offer. After Hu Yaobang's downfall in 1986, this event was also included as one of his wrongdoings.

Wednesday, May 7, 2008

NYT Archive 1989: Tactics and Sincerity Of Students

It was a relatively quiet period in Beijing after May 4, 1989. So, New York Times took the time to examine what it had witnessed so far in its May 7 edition. In particular, Nicholas Kristof observed something odd:
For anyone tempted to think that rebellious Chinese students must be fighting for capitalism and multi-party democracy, a banner fluttering over People's University marchers on Thursday was a rude shock. It read, ''We firmly support the correct leadership of the Communist Party.''
If South Korean university students are at the militant extreme, totally rejecting the Government and battering lines of police with firebombs and wooden staves, then Chinese demonstrators are at the peaceful extreme.
They sometimes go out of their way to say nice things about the Communist Party, even when it is clear they do not believe them, and they overwhelm the police as much with courtesy as with force.
Certainly, anyone would be amused by such tactics:
When approaching lines of the police, the students try to ingratiate themselves by chanting, ''The people love the people's police; the people's police love the people.'' After some hard pushing, but never any blows, the police usually give way to the students.
That is when the demonstrators pause to bellow, ''Thank you, police.'' A few students are even assigned to pick up any shoes lost in the shoving and return them to their owners, be they police or protesters.
Such tactics, which resemble those employed in the Philippine uprising rather than those in South Korea, have been enormously successful so far. It has been difficult for the Communist Party to crack down on those who politely call on the party to uphold its own ideals of honesty and democracy. And the students' charm has won grins and support from many ordinary workers.
But Kristof was also correct when he pointed out that students' pro-Communist rule declarations were not entirely sincere. It was done at least partly for tactical reasons. Or at the best, the students were simply recognizing the reality, as Wang Dan was quoted in the article:
Several of the student movement's leaders have said that they would consider joining the Communist Party at some point in their careers. Even Wang Dan, the Beijing University student leader who is regarded as among the most aggressive in the movement, scarcely paused when he was asked if he supported the leading role of the Communist Party in China.
''You can say I support correct leadership by the Communist Party,'' Mr. Wang said, putting emphasis on the word ''correct.'' He seemed to mean that he was willing to tolerate the leading role of the party, so long as it was upright and permitted greater democracy.
In other news on that day, NYT focused on the on-going reconciliation across the strait with the visit of Taiwan's financial minister, as well as the status of Tibetans in Nepal.

Outspoken Columnist Fired

Chang Ping (长平), a columnist who had ignited a raging internet battle over freedom of speech in China, had been fired from his job as deputy editor and lead writer at the magazine Southern Metropolis Weekly.

Since the start of the most recent riot in Tibet, Chang Ping had been writing about the fair coverage, or the lack thereof, of the event in China. His blog posts, provocatively titled as How To Find The Truth About Lhasa, I Am Not Your Enemy, and the latest, My Cowardice And Incompetence, were regular targets of internet attack. He was even publicly denounced in the Beijing Evening News.

Tuesday, May 6, 2008

NYT Archive 1989: Press Freedom in May

Back in April, 1989, when the emerging student movement was showing its unprecedented strength, Party General Zhao Ziyang inexplicably left Beijing, and indeed the country, for a previously scheduled but long state visit to North Korea. The Premier Li Peng was left in charge of handling the trouble. By all indication, however, Zhao Ziyang had personally approved the publication of the infamous People's Daily editorial on April 26, which had poured fuel into the raging fire.

Zhao Ziyang did not get back to Beijing until early May. But he got a window of opportunity to showcase a more moderate approach towards the movement. First, he gave a speech at the Asian Development Bank meeting that was oscillatory to the students, markedly different in tone from the editorial. Somehow this important speech was not covered by New York Times at the time.

Next, Zhao Ziyang made his boldest move yet: opening the press. With his instruction, pretty much all restrictions on news reporting were lifted overnight. On May 6, 1989, NYT noticed this sea change in Beijing's newspapers:
After studiously ignoring pro-democracy protests for the last two weeks, China's official newspapers seemed today to display a new openness in their reports of a mass demonstration held here on Thursday.
Photographs of streets filled with students waving banners as far as the eye could see ran on the front pages of most newspapers. The newspapers also reported details of demonstrations not only in the capital but in many other cities. Some of those demonstrations had not previously been reported.
and
'Several hundred thousand spectators watched the students marching along the streets, and many of them donated cold drinks and food,'' read part of an article from the official People's Daily. ''As long as there is corruption, this country will never be stable,'' the article quoted a banner as saying.
Such articles were unusual only given the Government's previous determination to avoid references to the demonstrations. It is not clear if today's articles and photos in the official press mark a permanent step toward openness that will let Chinese people learn about events as they happen.
Today's newspapers also quoted the Communist Party General Secretary, Zhao Ziyang, as saying that corruption occurs partly because there is a ''lack of openness in the system of work.'' That seemed to be another call for more openness in Chinese society, one of the major student demands.
This unprecedented and unusual practice of press freedom in China would last the month of May, through the thick and thin of the upcoming drama. It would then become a thing of past, never to be seen again.

Monday, May 5, 2008

NYT Archive 1989: Recapping The Wide-Spread Demonstration

On May 5, New York Times provided a recap of the demonstration one day earlier, showing how much it had spread by this time:
A defiant and enthusiastic crowd of more than 100,000 workers and students forced its way through police cordons in the capital today to demand more democracy, and smaller demonstrations were held in many other cities around China.
The occasion for the marches today was the 70th anniversary of famous nationalist demonstrations in Beijing that led to the May 4 Movement, which led a generation of Chinese intellectuals to seek a major re-examination of Chinese society. The movement also foreshadowed the rise of the Communist Party.

Outside of Beijing, the report said that 20,000 or more marched in Shanghai, 8,000 to 10,000 showed up in Changchun, and numerous demonstrated in other cities.

But more importantly, Nicholas Kristof observed in Beijing that workers were joining en mass. In fact, he claimed that workers had outnumbered students on this day:
While the nucleus of the crowd was still students, they were easily outnumbered by the young workers who came to express dissatisfaction with the inflation, corruption and other frustrations that most bother them. Inflation is running at a rate of about 27 percent a year.
''I hope student demonstrations will make the Government do something about inflation,'' said Yuan Jun, an iron worker who came from out of town to join in the demonstration. ''But even if the students don't bring up the inflation problem, I'll still support them. They demand press freedom, which is something we need, too. Now we have no freedom at all.''
Worker participation in the recent unrest has been one of the Government's greatest fears, but today the workers still seemed to be coalescing around the students rather than forming their own organizations. This is likely to give the Government some reprieve, particularly as most of the students seem to be planning to end their class boycott and focus their attention once more on their books.
In an accompanying report, Sheryl WuDunn interviewed several of these workers, who were much more concerned with inflation and corruption than democracy.

Among the non-students who had joined in, a group of journalists' action was captured in the NYT:
Several hundred journalists for official publications gathered today in front of the official New China News Agency to protest false and biased reporting and to call for the reinstatement of Qin Benli, the editor of a Shanghai newspaper and one of the boldest journalists in the country. Mr. Qin was dismissed last week after insisting on publishing comments that supported student demonstrators.
Students were delighted to receive support from the journalists, and as they marched by they shouted, ''Long live journalists with a conscience!''
The journalists shouted back: ''We support you! Long live the students!''
The leader of these journalists had contacted Shen Tong's media center at Beida beforehand, whose volunteers helped making flags and banners for them.

Meanwhile, the student movement itself appeared to be near its end. NYT failed to mention the harshly made decision to end the class boycott. The decision was announced in Tiananmen Square by the President of Beijing Students Autonomous Federation, who would soon pay the price of being expelled from BSAF for doing so. But the resuming class call was cheered and applauded by the crowd, who had grown wary of the weeks of continuous protests:

Wuer Kaixi, a student leader, told the crowd that the students reserved the right to hold further demonstrations, but for now there was no clear issue that seemed likely to send large numbers of them into the streets.
By Monday, May 8, students in all colleges had resumed class except for Beida and Beijing Normal University, which decided to continue their boycotts to keep the pressure on for a meaningful dialog with the government.

Hong Kong Run For Tiananmen

About 50 activists staged a 19-kilometer run in Hong Kong to persuade Beijing to reverse the verdict on Tiananmen Massacre. The event is organized by the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China. The distance symbolizes the 19 years since the crackdown.

Walk Against Chemical Plant in Chengdu

After the successful "flash mob" style protests in Xiamen and Shanghai earlier, another protest occurred in the inland city of Chengdu, the capital of Sichuan province. According to Reuters, about 200 people marched peacefully for about two hours on May 4, protesting against construction of a major petrochemical complex.

Once again, it is not billed as a protest march per se, which would lead to endless trouble. But the event was simply an occurrence of many people "took a stroll" together on the street. It even got a written up in the official Beijing Daily.